Why NFL Officials Still Rely on Traditional Football Spotting: The Human Element Amid Technological Advances

Next season, the NFL plans to work with its Competition Committee to test new technology for virtual line-to-gain measurements. However, officials will still be responsible for spotting the football.

Currently, there’s no technology in line to help decide forward progress. This became a hot topic during the AFC championship game when Josh Allen was short on a crucial fourth-and-1 play in the fourth quarter against Kansas City, contributing to Buffalo’s narrow 32-29 loss.

This offseason, the NFL tested Sony’s Hawk-Eye tracking system for measuring first downs. This tech could tell officials instantly if a first down was achieved after the ball is spotted.

It’s important to note that this technology works only after the ball has been placed. The NFL has traditionally used two bright orange sticks and a chain — known as the chain gang — to measure first downs, which will still serve as backup.

“This technology can’t replace the human role in deciding where forward progress ends,” stated NFL executive Kimberly Fields. “There will always be a human official to spot the ball. Once that happens, the tech conducts the measurement.”

During the season, there were about 12 measurements needed each week. With the new system, that time could drop significantly from 75 seconds to just 35 seconds.

Since 2017, NFL balls have included Zebra microchips, which power the NFL’s Next Gen Stats. These chips also attach to players’ equipment, offering valuable data for teams and fans. However, they aren’t precise enough to determine key game moments like where a player was tackled or who recovered a loose ball.

The NFL started using boundary line cameras in Week 5 to aid in replay reviews. These cameras, installed in all 30 stadiums, focus on key areas like the end line and the sidelines. They are mostly used for scoring plays, turnovers, and in the final two minutes of games.

There are discussions about extending their use for coaches’ challenges, but that would need approval from the Competition Committee.

Fields also mentioned experiments with smart watches for back judges, aimed at speeding up decisions related to the play clock.

“We want to make the game faster and more accurate,” Fields explained. “Any technology we pursue must improve processes and support our officials. We rigorously test everything to ensure it makes the game better.”

___

AP NFL: https://apnews.com/hub/nfl