I Taste-Tested the New Reese’s Peanut Butter Cup with Oreo Filling: Here’s What You Need to Know!

Peanut butter and Oreos have long been considered a tasty match. Now, Reese’s has teamed up with Oreo to create a new treat that blends the two favorites: Reese’s Oreo Peanut Butter Cups. But how do these new snacks taste?

Getting my hands on them wasn’t straightforward. Described as a top-secret project by some, the buzz around this collaboration made them hard to find. I finally managed to grab a bag of Reese’s Oreo mini cups after several attempts, which only heightened my excitement.

When I opened one, I noticed a white crème layer on top instead of the usual milk chocolate. This change is meant to mimic the filling of an Oreo. Inside, I found the classic Reese’s peanut butter, enhanced by a slight crunch from Oreo cookie bits.

So, how did it taste? As a huge fan of Reese’s, I was a bit let down. The Oreo flavor didn’t shine through as I hoped. The dominant taste was still the familiar chocolate and peanut butter combo. The Oreo bits added some crunch, but overall, it felt similar to a regular Reese’s mini cup.

In today’s snack market, collaborations are common. For example, flavors like peanut butter and jelly or Chocolate Lava Reese’s have gained popularity. According to recent surveys, 70% of consumers enjoy buying new snack combinations when they hit the shelves. Some users on social media have expressed their hopes for a treat that features a peanut butter coating with Oreo filling, reflecting a desire for even bolder flavor combinations.

Despite my mixed feelings, the good news is that these Reese’s Oreo Cups are here to stay in the Reese’s lineup, while the Oreo cookies will be available until they run out, returning for good in early 2026.

For further insights on this collaboration, you can check out more from The Wall Street Journal.

Source link

peanut butter, Oreos, Kaitlin Reilly