Shockwaves in Tech: A Judge Challenges Apple’s Dominance Over the App Store

Judge Yvonne Gonzalez Rogers has made a significant ruling in the legal battle between Epic Games and Apple. Effective immediately, Apple can no longer charge fees on purchases made outside of its apps. Additionally, the company is prohibited from restricting developers on how they direct users to external purchasing options.

This decision is a big win for Epic Games, as Rogers stated that Apple "willfully" failed to follow her earlier orders from 2021. She highlighted Apple’s disregard for the legal process, saying, “That [Apple] thought this Court would tolerate such insubordination was a gross miscalculation.”

The judge also referred the case to the U.S. attorney, which could lead to potential criminal contempt charges against Apple.

In her ruling, Rogers clarified several restrictions on Apple. Notably, Epic Games CEO Tim Sweeney announced that the company plans to bring Fortnite back to the U.S. App Store soon. He even proposed a deal: if Apple allows a fee-free framework globally, Epic will return Fortnite and cease ongoing legal disputes.

Generally, Apple takes a 30% commission on in-app purchases. While a past ruling compelled Apple to permit alternative payment methods, the company responded with its own commission demands, which left many developers dissatisfied, Epic included.

Rogers emphasized that Apple aimed to preserve a lucrative revenue stream, even after being instructed to comply with the court’s ruling. Inside Apple, there were voices advocating for compliance, but CEO Tim Cook ultimately chose a different direction, opting to listen to CFO Luca Maestri instead.

This ruling represents not just a legal milestone but also a potential shift in how technology companies manage in-app purchases. As consumers increasingly demand more control over their spending, this case may impact similar disputes in the tech industry.

For further reading on this legal case, you can check this ruling.

Check out this related article: Barcelona vs Inter: Analyzing Yamal’s Brilliance, Inter’s Lightning Start, and Dumfries’ Surprising Double!