Discover Why This Chicago Pizza Shop is One of Food Network’s Top 50 Must-Try Slices in the U.S.!

Chicago is a pizza lover’s paradise, and one spot has just made headlines. Pie-Eyed Pizzeria, located in the River West neighborhood, was named one of the “50 best pizza slices to try” in the U.S. for 2025 by the Food Network.

This lively pizzeria, found at 1111 W. Chicago Ave., is known for its unique vibe, mixing two styles: thin-crust and deep-dish pizzas. The décor features band posters, celebrating heavy metal and rock music. In fact, one of their popular pies pays tribute to the band Gwar, who performed at Riot Fest. Customers love the atmosphere, with one Google reviewer noting, “I would come here just for the music. Always playing 90’s alt.”

Open until about 2 a.m. on Fridays and Saturdays, Pie-Eyed makes it easy to grab a late-night slice, with prices starting at $6.75.

Interestingly, only a month ago, Chowhound called Milly’s Pizza in the Pan another top contender in Illinois, labeling it “hands down the best pizza.” They offer a limited number of pies each day, making them a unique choice for pizza enthusiasts.

In recent years, Chicago pizza has seen a growing trend where owners focus on fresh ingredients and unique flavors. Chef and pizza expert Tony Gemignani notes that local pizzerias are increasingly experimenting with different toppings and styles to stand out. This drive for creativity may be part of what makes spots like Pie-Eyed so appealing.

Pizza is more than just food; it’s part of Chicago’s culture. A 2023 survey revealed that 83% of Chicago residents believe pizza is an essential part of their identity. As pizzerias evolve, they continue to reflect the city’s spirit and innovation.

To explore the complete list of the “50 best slices in America,” you can check it out here.

Source link

chicago food, Food & Drink