Will Shedeur Sanders Shine with the Browns? Ranking the Top 7 Drafted QBs on Their Likelihood of Success

The 2025 NFL Draft featured a group of quarterbacks that didn’t garner much pre-draft hype. While Cam Ward was the standout pick for the Tennessee Titans, the selection of other quarterbacks felt more like afterthoughts. Jaxson Dart was the only other QB chosen in the first round, with Tyler Shough picked in the second, and Jalen Milroe and Dillon Gabriel rounding out the draft class.

Comparing this year to last, six quarterbacks were taken in the first 12 picks in 2024, signaling a leaner selection in 2025. The success of these QBs will depend largely on their ability to exceed expectations, especially since many are starting their careers as backups. Let’s dive into the seven quarterbacks drafted this year, focusing on their potential to thrive in the NFL.

1. Cam Ward, Titans
Why he might succeed:
Ward brings impressive arm strength and leadership skills, honed during his time at multiple universities, including Incarnate Word and Washington State. The Titans see promise in him, emphasizing the importance of a supportive environment for quarterbacks. With a strong work ethic and football IQ, Ward can make plays both in and out of the pocket.

Why he might fail:
Ward’s inclination to take risks could backfire, especially on a team that struggled last season. While the Titans are under new management, they still have challenges ahead, such as fixing an offense that had a rocky previous year.

2. Jalen Milroe, Seahawks
Why he might succeed:
Milroe caught attention with dynamic performances, notably against Georgia. The Seahawks plan to utilize his athleticism in a run-heavy scheme. With a revamped offensive line, there’s potential for Milroe to thrive under smart coaching.

Why he might fail:
His opportunity hinges on Sam Darnold’s performance. If Darnold excels, Milroe may remain on the sidelines longer than desired. Additionally, there’s pressure on him to improve as a passer.

3. Jaxson Dart, Giants
Why he might succeed:
Dart has talented coaches, including Brian Daboll, who successfully developed Josh Allen. With a solid group of receivers and running backs around him, Dart has tools for success.

Why he might fail:
The pressure is real for the Giants this season with a shaky management situation. Dart could face challenges if he’s thrust into action too soon, especially if the team isn’t performing well.

4. Tyler Shough, Saints
Why he might succeed:
Shough’s height and arm strength stand out, making him a solid candidate to step in for the Saints if Derek Carr’s health continues to be an issue. His opportunity to showcase his skills could come earlier than expected.

Why he might fail:
The Saints’ offensive setup poses challenges, as they’ve struggled to find consistency. Shough must also stay healthy given his past injuries.

5. Will Howard, Steelers
Why he might succeed:
Howard’s experience in high-pressure situations could benefit the Steelers. With an improved offensive line and talented teammates, he could make an impact, especially if he sits and learns under a veteran like Aaron Rodgers.

Why he might fail:
His success in college doesn’t automatically translate to the NFL, where competition is fierce. Additionally, Howard’s future depends heavily on Rodgers’ decision-making and health.

6. Shedeur Sanders, Browns
Why he might succeed:
Motivated after being drafted later than expected, Sanders has the potential to prove critics wrong. The Browns’ current quarterback turmoil creates space for him to compete for a starting role.

Why he might fail:
Sanders has to transition from a simplified college scheme to a complex NFL offense. He must focus on football over branding and tackle the challenge of an unstable environment in Cleveland.

7. Dillon Gabriel, Browns
Why he might succeed:
Gabriel’s previous accolades suggest he can adapt quickly. The Browns’ preference for Gabriel in the draft indicates they see potential for him to thrive within their system.

Why he might fail:
At 5-foot-11, Gabriel’s size might limit his options, and he faces stiff competition from veterans. Without a strong initial impact, he risks being overlooked.

The journey for these quarterbacks will not be easy. Each has unique strengths and weaknesses, and their success hinges on both their performance and the support they receive from their teams. With evolving dynamics in the league, the coming season will reveal who rises to the challenge.

For those interested in detailed analyses or team strategies, check out resources like ESPN or NFL.com for the latest updates.

Source link

Cleveland Browns, New Orleans Saints, New York Giants, Pittsburgh Steelers, Seattle Seahawks, Tennessee Titans, NFL