I’m skeptical about any positive outcomes from meetings between Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin. It feels like a bad rerun of Trump’s past negotiations, like the ones with the Taliban, which led to chaos in Afghanistan.
Take the recent Alaska summit, for example. After some vague messaging, Trump expected huge breakthroughs. Instead, he left with little more than Putin’s trademark smirk and a spotlight on Russia’s supposed triumph. Ukraine was sidelined once again, forced to watch as others negotiated its fate.
Analyst Sir Lawrence Freedman pointed out the disasters that could have unfolded. While Trump avoided some of Putin’s more extreme demands, he stepped back from even seeking a ceasefire. This shift played right into Moscow’s hands.
The visuals were cringe-worthy. It looked more like a movie scene than a serious diplomatic meeting. Rows of fighter jets and a military show seemed designed to intimidate, but they only reinforced Putin’s status as a global player. The awkward handshakes and grins felt empty and theatrical.
When Trump’s team came out of the meeting, the mood was deflated. They looked like they had just watched their plans crumble. Meanwhile, Putin was all smiles, basking in the treatment typically reserved for respected leaders, even as Russia continued its assault on Ukraine.
Public sentiment hasn’t been great either. Many questioned if Trump’s diplomatic antics were helping or hurting the situation. Some hoped for a genuine ceasefire, while others worried it was just a front for further Russian aggression.
What was clear after the summit was this: America wasn’t stepping forward for peace. Instead, it was retreating. Allies like Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky expressed willingness to negotiate but emphasized that any talks should start with halting the violence. Ceasefires might be fragile, but they create room for dialogue. Dropping that essential step allowed Russia to negotiate unchecked while continuing its attacks.
Post-summit, Trump shifted his stance. He started claiming that mere ceasefires were inadequate, suggesting that only a complete peace agreement mattered. This change handed Putin a propaganda win without offering anything in return.
Zelensky’s current situation is tough. While meeting with Trump again in Washington, he’s joined by key European leaders. This coalition shows that Ukraine is not isolated. Countries like Finland, now part of NATO, understand the threats posed by Russia. They stress that neutrality isn’t safe anymore.
Zelensky has to walk a tightrope. He can’t seem like he’s bending to pressure that might undermine Ukraine’s sovereignty. Yet, he needs to keep Trump engaged for crucial support. His coalition underscores the stakes: this isn’t just Ukraine’s fight; it’s Europe’s too.
Experts warn that the path Trump seeks is unrealistic. Real peace would require extensive negotiations on issues like reparations and security. Russia’s demands lean toward subjugation, while Ukraine demands accountability. These aren’t easy talks and the solutions won’t come quickly.
Throughout, Trump treats diplomacy like a real estate deal—transactional and superficial. When Zelensky explained Ukraine’s constitutional constraints on territorial exchanges, Trump dismissed him. That quip showed a lack of understanding: Ukraine didn’t start this war and shouldn’t have to yield its land to appease an aggressor.
This conflict is about more than just borders; it’s about whether free nations can defend their sovereignty against bullies. The outcome here will set a dangerous precedent. If Putin’s aggression goes unchecked and the U.S. does nothing, it signals to others that might makes right.
The Alaska summit confirmed many fears: Trump is easily swayed by Putin and overlooks the hard truths about sovereignty. Zelensky and his allies must focus on core principles during negotiations—sovereignty shouldn’t be on the table, and freedom isn’t for sale.
If the U.S. abandons real diplomacy for fantasy peace, the consequences could haunt generations. True peace requires justice, not submission. Ukraine deserves better than to be treated as just another pawn in someone else’s game.
For more information, you can read further at The Bulwark.
