On April 28, Princeton political science professors Stephen Macedo and Frances Lee discussed their book, “In Covid’s Wake: How Our Politics Failed Us,” at a Rockefeller Center event. They argued that COVID-19 lockdowns didn’t effectively stop the virus’s spread and that these measures had negative impacts on education.
About 240 people participated, both in-person and online, to hear them present their insights. They highlighted the failures of institutions like science and journalism during the pandemic. Macedo pointed out that after previous pandemics, experts warned against strict measures like contact tracing and quarantines. Yet, when COVID-19 hit, many of these recommendations were ignored.
Lee noted the significant setbacks in student education due to school closures. For instance, the National Assessment of Educational Progress showed notable declines in math and reading skills since the pandemic began. She found no evidence that strict restrictions helped reduce COVID transmission better than more lenient ones.
The speakers emphasized that many European countries reopened schools much earlier than the United States, which kept many schools closed for over a year. This slow response highlighted the inability to learn from other countries’ experiences.
Lee elaborated that the public’s reaction to COVID-19 serves as a warning against ignoring dissenting opinions, suggesting that refusing to engage with critics can lead to extreme policy decisions. The impact of teacher unions in prolonging school closures was also discussed, with Lee emphasizing that political divides played a larger role.
Attendees responded positively to the event. Marcella Arnesen ’28 found the discussion enlightening, noting the lack of discourse following the pandemic’s onset. Ben Merrett ’28 appreciated the refreshing perspective, even if he didn’t fully agree with everything shared.
This conversation ties into broader societal challenges post-pandemic. According to recent polls from the Pew Research Center, only 29% of Americans trust government agencies’ handling of public health crises, reflecting a growing mistrust in institutions. This decline in trust may shape future policies and public health responses as the country continues to navigate the lasting effects of the pandemic.
You can read more insights in their book, “In Covid’s Wake: How Our Politics Failed Us,” and stay updated on pandemic strategies through reputable sources like The World Health Organization and CDC.
